Traditional Pregnancy and Postpartum Practices in Malaysia: “Hot” vs “Cold” Foods

Introduction

In multicultural Malaysia, traditional pregnancy and postpartum practices are deeply influenced by the concepts of “hot” and “cold” foods in each major ethnic community – Malay, Chinese, and Indian. These beliefs stem from humoral theories and ancient health philosophies, where maintaining a balance between “hot” and “cold” elements in the body is thought to ensure a healthy pregnancy and recovery after childbirth. This section explores how each culture categorises foods as “hot” or “cold,” the logic behind these classifications, and how prenatal (pregnancy) and postpartum practices reflect these beliefs. We also compare these traditions to modern medical understanding to determine which practices have benefits, which are myths, and whether they should still be followed today.

---

Malay Traditions: Hot-Cold Beliefs in Pregnancy and Postpartum

Cultural Background:

Malay traditional medicine historically incorporated ideas from Chinese, Indian (Ayurvedic), and Arabic humoral systems, layered onto indigenous beliefs about the natural world. The Malay humoral concept (panas vs sejuk) became closely tied to reproductive health. Interestingly, Malay beliefs diverged from other humoral systems in that “coldness” is associated with health and fertility, while “heat” is linked to illness and sterility. In other words, maintaining a “cool” body state is viewed as crucial for a safe pregnancy, whereas excessive “heat” is seen as harmful to mother and fetus. This underpins many Malay pregnancy taboos and postpartum practices.

Hot vs Cold Food Classification:

Malays classify foods based not on temperature, but on perceived qualities. According to anthropological studies:

“Hot” foods (panas) are those that are rich, oily, or spicy – for example, animal proteins and fats, spices (like chili, ginger, turmeric), alcohol, salty and bitter foods. These are thought to increase heat in the body.

“Cold” foods (sejuk) are typically watery, sour, or slimy in nature. Juicy fruits and vegetables (e.g. watermelon, cucumber), plants that exude slime or sap (lendir), sour or astringent-tasting plants (kelat), and any vines/creepers are considered “cold”. Such foods are believed to cool the body.

Malays also speak of “windy” foods (berangin), which cause gas or air in the body. Examples include watermelon, jackfruit, bean sprouts, and long beans, which are said to create excessive “wind” that could cause bloating or discomfort.

Prenatal Beliefs (Pregnancy):

Uniquely, Malay culture historically did not impose as many food restrictions during pregnancy as during postpartum.

However, certain taboos are still common. Many Malay pregnant women avoid foods deemed “panas” (hot) or “tajam” (sharp) for fear they could harm the pregnancy. Pineapple – especially unripe pineapple – is a well-known forbidden food, as it’s considered extremely “hot” and believed to trigger uterine contractions leading to miscarriage.

In a Kuala Lumpur survey, 70% of Malay pregnant women reported avoiding pineapple due to its alleged abortifacient effect. Other taboos include certain “hot” spices and fruits (e.g. durian, chili, ginger, rambutan) and even specific drinks: about half of respondents avoided “hot foods” in general, and ~60% avoided sugarcane juice (considered “sharp”) during pregnancy. “Cold” foods were less commonly avoided during pregnancy (only ~12.5% avoided “cold” items) – likely because Malays view excess heat as more dangerous to a fetus than cold.

The primary reason given for these avoidances was fear of miscarriage (95% of respondents), followed by fears of bleeding, birth deformities, or difficult labor. For example, many believe an overheated body or womb (from “hot” foods) could cause pregnancy loss, reflecting the view that coolness preserves pregnancy.

While these beliefs are deeply ingrained, it’s important to note that modern medicine finds no evidence that consuming pineapple or other “hot” foods causes miscarriage. Unfortunately, strict adherence to pregnancy food taboos can have downsides: one study found women practicing these avoidances had significantly higher rates of inadequate weight gain during pregnancy (71% vs 52% among those who did not avoid foods), potentially due to missing out on nutrients.

Postpartum Confinement Practices: In Malay tradition, the postpartum period (locally called pantang) lasts 44 days, during which new mothers observe strict regimens to restore health. The underlying belief is that childbirth leaves the mother in a “cold” and vulnerable state – now she must be warmed up and protected from “wind” to recover.

Key features of Malay confinement include:

“Heating” Therapies:

New mothers undergo daily practices to warm the body. This includes bertungku (hot compress using heated stones or iron on the abdomen and body), berdiang (heat treatment by sitting near a brazier or heated bricks infused with herbs), and barut/bengkung (tight abdominal binding with cloth) to help the womb retract.

Mothers may also be given warm herbal baths (water infused with medicinal leaves) but are often advised to avoid cold water and even regular bathing early on to prevent “wind” entering the body. All these measures reflect the priority on keeping the mother warm and “closing” her body.

Dietary Restrictions: Malay confinement diet strongly emphasizes “hot” foods and tonics and prohibits “cold” or “windy” foods. Cold or cooling items like cucumber, watermelon, coconut water, cabbage, leafy greens, pumpkin, and most fruits/vegetables are avoided as they are thought to hinder healing.

Foods considered “windy” (e.g. long beans, jackfruit, “gassy” vegetables) or “poisonous” (bisa, often referring to certain seafoods or overly acidic foods) are also banned to prevent bloating, dizziness or slow wound healing. Examples of taboo foods for Malay mothers include cucumber, bamboo shoots, pineapples, crabs, and some fish – all believed to introduce cold, wind or “toxins” into the recuperating body. Instead, the mother’s diet centers on warming, protein-rich foods.

Traditionally rice with lean meats (like chicken) is common, accompanied by liberal amounts of spices (ginger, pepper, turmeric) to “heat” the body. Malay mothers also consume herbal tonics such as jamu (a drink or paste of mixed herbs) or akar kayu decoctions (root/herb tonics) daily, which are regarded as “hot” remedies that expel wind, cleanse the womb, and boost strength. Ginger in particular is a cornerstone of the confinement diet for its warming and circulation-boosting properties.

These postpartum practices are ubiquitous among Malay women – one study in Pahang found 100% of Malay mothers surveyed observed some traditional confinement practices for an average of 44 days. The intended goals are to purge “wind” from the body, help the uterus shrink, promote blood circulation, and fortify the mother’s health and milk supply. Culturally, there is also a belief in avoiding “angin meroyan” (a postpartum mental disturbance attributed to wind/cold) by following these rules.

Modern Perspective on Malay Practices:

Some aspects of the Malay postpartum regimen do have practical benefits – for example, dedicated rest for 6 weeks, abdominal wrapping for core support, and warm compresses that may soothe muscle aches. However, many of the dietary taboos are not scientifically substantiated and can be overly restrictive. Researchers note that Malay confinement diets often exclude entire food groups (fruits, most vegetables, “oily” foods), which “causes limited food choices that may affect the mother’s nutritional intake.”.

In the Pahang survey, women avoided even nutritious items like tubers and leafy greens for being “cold,” and over half avoided soy sauce believing it worsens wound healing. Health professionals worry such practices, if taken to extremes, could slow recovery rather than help. They recommend a more balanced diet during confinement, adding back permissible fruits and vegetables to ensure adequate vitamins and fiber, while still respecting culturally acceptable practices for comfort. In short, maintaining warmth and avoiding obvious irritants is fine, but Malay mothers are encouraged not to forgo nutrition in the name of tradition.

---

Chinese Traditions: Yin and Yang in Maternal Care

Cultural Background:

Malaysian Chinese practices derive from traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and the yin-yang philosophy. In this view, health is about balancing yin (cool, cold) and yang (warm, hot) energies.

Pregnancy and postpartum are seen as times when the balance can be disrupted, requiring careful management of diet and environment to protect the mother and baby. Generally, pregnancy is considered a “hot” condition in later stages (due to increased metabolic heat), whereas childbirth is believed to drain the mother’s energy and heat, leaving her in a “cold” state that must be warmed during postpartum.

The Chinese community practices “confinement” (zuò yuèzi 坐月子) for about one month after delivery, which is a strict regimen to restore the yang (heat) and keep out yin (cold).

Yin (Cooling) vs Yang (Warming) Foods:

In Chinese tradition, every food has an intrinsic thermal nature. The logic is often metaphorical – foods that grow in water or cold/damp environments are classified as “cooling” (yin), while foods that require lots of sun or have spice are “heaty” (yang). For example, lotus root is cold because it grows in water, and root vegetables like turnips are considered cooling because they grow underground in damp soil. On the other hand, ginger, garlic, meats, and peppers are heaty since they can raise body warmth.

The goal is to adjust one’s diet to maintain balance: if the body is in a cold state, eat more hot (yang) foods and vice versa. During zuò yuèzi, yang foods predominate because the mother is assumed to be deficient in heat and blood after childbirth.

Prenatal Beliefs (Pregnancy):

Traditional Chinese pregnancy advice is less uniform than postpartum, but many Chinese Malaysians do observe certain dietary precautions. A common belief is to avoid excess “cooling” foods in early pregnancy to prevent chilling the womb and impairing fetal growth or causing miscarriage. For instance, some families caution against eating foods like watermelon, bitter gourd, or cold drinks in the first trimester, believing they could “make the uterus cold” or reduce circulation to the womb.

Interestingly, there are also folk taboos about specific foods: one cultural belief is that eating crabs might make the baby mischievous, or eating bananas (especially green bananas) in early pregnancy could cause miscarriage. (These notions are not medically grounded – there’s no evidence that a banana or crab can harm a fetus – but they illustrate how traits are metaphorically linked to foods.) Chinese pregnant women often favor a moderate diet that leans warm (e.g. meats, ginger chicken soup) but not excessively hot.

They also consume special foods believed to benefit the baby, such as bird’s nest soup in mid-pregnancy for a healthy complexion (a popular but unproven practice). By the final weeks, some TCM practitioners might recommend “cooling” foods or herbal teas to avoid a baby that is too “heaty” (which in TCM is associated with neonatal jaundice).

Overall, Chinese prenatal food practices vary by family, but the common thread is to avoid extremes and keep the yin-yang balanced for mother and fetus. Any foods thought to potentially disrupt pregnancy (whether labeled heaty or cooling in different contexts) are avoided out of caution.

Modern medical professionals clarify that there is no scientific need to avoid nutritious fruits or vegetables like papaya, pineapple, citrus, etc., during pregnancy, as “no documented case of miscarriage from eating these foods” exists. The key is a well-balanced diet; a pregnant woman can safely eat most foods in moderation unless there’s a specific medical contraindication.

Postpartum Confinement (Zuo Yuezi): Chinese confinement is highly elaborate. For approximately 30–40 days after birth, the new mother “sits the month” at home, cared for by family or a confinement nanny. The overarching principle is to prevent any “cold” influence from reaching the mother, as her body is considered weak and cold after delivery.

Key aspects include:

Environmental Measures:

The mother is kept warm and indoors. Traditionally, she should not be exposed to cold air or wind – this means no fan or air-conditioner, and windows kept closed to avoid drafts.

In the past (and occasionally still), women were not allowed to bathe or wash hair for the first 1–2 weeks postpartum for fear that cold water or evaporation could introduce “wind” into the body and cause arthritis or headaches later.

After a couple of weeks, bathing is permitted only with warm water boiled with herbs (such as bitter gourd vine or mugwort) and absolutely no cold water is added to cool it. Even then, washing the hair is delayed and, when done, the hair must be dried immediately to prevent “chill” entering the scalp.

While hygiene is important, these customs persist in many families, though modern mothers may modify them (e.g. using warm water showers and drying off quickly). Doctors note there is no medical basis for avoiding bathing – in fact, keeping clean helps prevent infection – but the practice is a cultural comfort for many.

Dietary Regimen: The Chinese confinement diet is perhaps the strictest in terms of hot/cold management. “Eating to restore yang” is the mantra.

The new mother’s meals feature plentiful “heaty” ingredients: old ginger, often in large quantities, is fried or boiled into nearly every dish; sesame oil and sometimes rice wine (or dom Benedictine liqueur) are used liberally in cooking meats to warm the body. A famous dish is ginger-kale chicken in rice wine, consumed daily. Other popular confinement foods include Chicken soup with ginger and black vinegar, pig’s trotters in vinegar, and kidney/liver stir-fried with ginger and sesame oil, all believed to replenish blood and heat.

In Sabah (East Malaysia), Chinese mothers even drink “lohiong” (rice wine) soup with chicken and ginger, aiming to expel wind and warm the body. Herbal tonics are also common: the mother may drink red dates and dried longan tea instead of plain water (to avoid “cold” plain water), and take brewed TCM herbal mixtures tailored for postpartum (ginseng, dang gui, peony root, etc., all warming in nature).

On the flip side, “cooling” foods are strictly avoided during the month. Most vegetables and fruits are deemed too cold (yin) and are cut out of the diet entirely. Family elders often insist that green vegetables will cause the mother’s stomach to bloat or her joints to ache, and that fruits like oranges or watermelon could give her chills or “dampness” in the body. For example, a Chinese mother might be told not to eat cabbage, cucumber, coconut, or oranges while confined. Even drinking plain water is discouraged (hence the red date tea as a warm alternative).

Instead of high-fiber plant foods, the diet leans on rice and meats (chicken, pork, fish). Only certain types of fish are allowed – “non-toxic” fish that won’t cause allergies or “itchiness,” such as threadfin, pomfret, or carp, usually cooked with ginger. This heavy diet is believed to help recovery, boost milk production, and replace lost blood.

However, nutritionally it can be imbalanced: one study of Chinese Malaysians in confinement found that although they ate plenty of protein (93% above recommended intake), their calorie intake was low and vitamin A and C intakes were only about half of the recommended levels. The avoidance of vegetables and fruits leads to deficiencies in vitamins and fiber if no supplements are taken. Indeed, confinement menus often have excess iron (from organ meats) and inadequate vitamin C, which could affect iron absorption and overall health.

Despite these concerns, Chinese confinement practice remains widely observed out of respect for tradition and elders’ advice. Many Chinese families genuinely feel that following zuo yuezi will “protect the mother’s future health,” preventing ailments like backaches or rheumatism in old age.

From a Western medical standpoint, some practices are beneficial: for example, zuo yuezi encourages the mother to eat more and avoid heavy housework, which does aid recovery and breastfeeding. Organized support and enforced rest allow the mother to heal and bond with her baby – a positive aspect noted across cultures.

On the other hand, several confinement habits are scientifically unfounded or even harmful (e.g. avoiding hydration with plain water, or not consuming fresh fruits/veg, or staying in a stuffy room without ventilation).

Doctors in Singapore and Malaysia have worked to “bust” common confinement myths, emphasizing that there is no harm in using a fan or air-conditioning for comfort (it won’t cause illness, and can help prevent heat rash in the tropical climate). They also stress that postpartum mothers must stay hydrated – drinking warm liquids is fine, but there is no reason to ban plain water, and in fact dehydration can reduce breast milk supply. As for the heavy use of alcohol and herbal supplements, moderation is urged: TCM herbs and rice wine are not medically necessary to “remove wind,” and excess alcohol could pass into breastmilk or worsen neonatal jaundice.

In summary, the Chinese hot-cold confinement system has cultural logic rooted in yin-yang balance, but modern medicine only supports some of its practices. Mothers can still enjoy the caring ritual of zuo yuezi – eating hearty meals, resting and staying warm – but should ensure adequate nutrition, hygiene, and hydration in line with medical advice.

---

Indian Traditions: Ayurvedic Perspectives on Pregnancy and Postpartum

Cultural Background:

Malaysian Indians (predominantly of South Indian heritage) draw on Ayurveda and Siddha medical traditions for pregnancy and postpartum care. In Ayurveda, health is governed by three doshas (body humors) – Vata (air), Pitta (fire), and Kapha (water/earth) – and foods/herbs have properties that can increase or decrease these doshas.

The concepts of “heating” vs “cooling” foods are well-developed in Ayurveda (known as “Ushna” vs “Shita” qualities). The logic is that certain foods produce warmth or stimulate digestion (heating), while others cool the body or calm the system (cooling).

Indian pregnancy and postpartum practices are built around balancing these effects: during pregnancy, cooling foods are often favored (to avoid excess heat which could harm the fetus), whereas in postpartum, heating foods and spices are emphasized to rejuvenate the mother’s body.

Prenatal Beliefs (Pregnancy):

In the Indian tradition, a pregnant woman is typically advised to avoid foods that are overly “heat-inducing”, especially in the early months, because too much internal heat is believed to increase the risk of miscarriage or preterm labor. A classic example is papaya – Indian communities widely hold that unripe papaya is very “hot” and can trigger miscarriage, so it is strictly avoided in pregnancy. (Modern studies have indeed shown papaya latex can cause uterine contractions in animals, lending a tiny bit of plausibility, but ripe papaya is generally safe; regardless, culturally it remains taboo.) Pineapple and sesame seeds are two other “heaty” ingredients often avoided by Indian mothers-to-be, due to similar fears of uterine stimulation. Instead, more “cooling” foods or those that soothe Pitta are recommended – for instance, coconut water, yogurt, mung beans, and foods with high water content are thought to keep the mother’s body cool and nourished.

Spicy, pungent, or fried foods are curtailed as pregnancy advances, since they are heating and also can aggravate heartburn (here Ayurveda and modern medicine agree!). Indian folklore also has non-food taboos (like not attending funerals or avoiding eclipse light), but focusing on diet: the idea is to maintain a gentle, cooling diet that keeps mother and baby comfortable.

Ayurvedic texts explicitly advise “cool” or neutral diet in pregnancy – one recent summary notes “cooling foods help soothe excess internal heat (Pitta) and are typically preferred during pregnancy”.

On the contrary, anything that sharply increases body heat or is too acidic (e.g. chilies, excessive ginger, pineapple) is moderated or avoided to protect the pregnancy. It’s worth noting these traditional guidelines should not stop pregnant women from eating a variety of fruits and vegetables – there is no scientific evidence that properly cooked or ripe “heaty” foods cause miscarriage.

Medical experts encourage Indian mothers to continue consuming nutritious foods (in moderation) and to view these hot-cold suggestions as optional. For example, skipping papaya is fine if it gives peace of mind, but one should not avoid all iron-rich leafy greens (some consider spinach “heaty”) or all protein for fear of “heat.” Balance is key.

Postpartum Confinement Practices:

Indian postpartum customs in Malaysia are quite similar to the Malay ones, with an overlapping emphasis on warmth, massage, and selective dieting.

Traditionally, the confinement period is about 30–40 days.

Key practices include:

Thermal care:

New mothers are kept warm at all times. Soon after delivery, the mother is allowed to bathe, but only in warm water infused with healing herbs like neem leaves, moringa (mengkudu) leaves, or other medicinal plants.

Bathing is done later in the morning (after sunrise) to avoid the cool pre-dawn air. Washing hair is restricted to every few days (day 3, 5, 7, etc.) and the hair must be quickly dried; an interesting belief is that leaving hair wet can cause “cold” and even postpartum depression in the mother.

The mother is often given an herbal body scrub (lulur) with turmeric paste during bath – turmeric has antimicrobial and warming qualities. After bathing, she is dressed warmly and may sit by a fire or heat lamp.

Massage (maalish) is a daily ritual: an experienced female relative or hired masseuse rubs the mother’s body with warm oils (such as neem oil, mustard oil, or coconut oil). This massage helps improve circulation, ease muscle pain, and is believed to release “trapped wind” from the body, similar to Malay jamu massage practices.

Abdominal binding is also done by some Indian mothers – a tight cloth (girdle) is wrapped around the belly after applying herbal oil, to firm up the abdomen and support the spine.

Notably, Indian tradition usually does not include the hot stone compress (bertungku) that Malays use, but the regular oil massage provides a related warming therapy.

As with other cultures, staying indoors and resting is enforced, and the mother and newborn only resume normal outings after the confinement period. Hindu families also have specific ceremonies (e.g. a naming whisper at birth, a prayer on day 16, first temple visit around day 30) which mark the end of the confinement.

Dietary Practices:

Ayurveda describes the first 42 days postpartum (the sutikakala period) as a time when the mother’s Vata dosha is elevated – in Western terms, the mother’s body is considered cold, dry, and “airy” after the loss of warmth and fluids in childbirth.

Thus, the diet given is dominantly heating, oily, and easy to digest to counteract Vata’s cold and light qualities. In practice, Indian Malaysian mothers are fed foods quite comparable to Malay jamu diets: lots of spices and warming ingredients to boost recovery.

Common confinement foods in the Indian community include: dhal or lentil soups, methi (fenugreek) porridge or drinks (fenugreek is ushna or heating and also known to promote lactation), and special sweet confections like gum laddoo (gond laddu) and turmeric milk.

One Malaysian Indian example is a porridge made of pounded garlic, turmeric, ginger, fenugreek, ajwain (carom seed), and dal cooked in ghee – this concoction is very warming and given to mothers daily to strengthen the body and improve breastmilk flow.

According to one source, spices such as black pepper, cardamom, anise, turmeric, and ginger are strongly encouraged in the mother’s diet, as they are thought to “rekindle the digestive fire (agni), balance vata, and aid uterus healing.”.

Certain foods are specifically noted for boosting milk production, like boiled fenugreek seeds and cumin (which are actually galactagogues in herbal medicine).

On the other hand, the mother must avoid “cold” or “windy” foods to prevent gas and indigestion in her or the baby. For example, cucumber, eggplant, jackfruit, and even grapes are avoided during confinement as they are considered either too cooling or likely to cause flatulence. Murungai (drumstick/moringa pods) are also listed as a “windy” food to avoid postpartum – somewhat ironically, drumstick leaves are given to increase iron in other contexts, but the pods might be seen as gassy. Cold drinks, citrus fruits, and anything raw are typically off-limits. Like the other cultures, Indian postpartum diet is protein-rich: meat (especially mutton or even shark meat) is encouraged as a strength-giving “hot” food in some communities. All beverages must be warm/hot – ice water is strictly forbidden.

Additionally, herbal tonics (sometimes called lehiyam or kashayam in Indian terms, analogous to makjun mentioned in Malay) are given to cleanse the womb and boost immunity. For instance, a herbal jam made of ingredients like dates, long pepper, ginger, and jaggery is taken each morning.

These Indian practices are aimed at a holistic recovery, aligning with Ayurveda’s counsel that a new mother should be lavished with heavy, warm, nourishing care for 6 weeks. The similarities with Malay traditions likely come from historical cross-influences and the universal need to keep mothers comfortable. As one study noted, “the basic factor in postnatal care emphasized by Malays, Chinese, and Indians is the fear of ‘wind’ and cold causing illness,” and all three observe some form of food restriction and thermal care.

Modern Perspective on Indian Practices:

Many of the Indian confinement practices hold up well alongside modern medicine. Keeping the mother warm (but not overheated) and massaging her can improve circulation and relaxation. Several spices used (turmeric, ginger, fenugreek) have known anti-inflammatory or lactation-promoting properties, so those traditional recipes may indeed benefit recovery in moderation.

However, as with the other cultures, extreme dietary restrictions could be problematic if they prevent a balanced intake. Fortunately, Indian confinement diets tend to include more variety (lentils, some vegetables like green leafy veggies in cooked form, dairy, etc.) compared to the strictly low-vegetable Chinese approach.

Still, nutritionists advise that mothers should not skip nutrient-dense “cold” foods entirely without good substitutes. For example, if she’s avoiding certain “gassy” vegetables like cabbage or beans, she should ensure she gets fiber and vitamins from other cooked veggies or supplements.

Hydration is another point: warm water is fine, but the mother must drink enough fluids even if plain cold water is avoided. Indian traditional drinks like ajjwain water (carom seed tea) or dill seed water are warm and can keep her hydrated.

Doctors generally support practices like using mild spices and herbal remedies postpartum as long as they’re safe, but they caution against any herbal concoction that is unknown or too alcoholic. They also note that gradually reintroducing a normal diet is important – by the end of the confinement, the mother should resume eating a full balanced diet to regain strength, rather than continuing very restrictive habits.

---

Comparing Traditions with Modern Medical Logic

Logic and Origins:

The hot-cold food paradigm in all three cultures is rooted in pre-modern understanding of health. These beliefs emerged to explain and prevent pregnancy or postpartum complications at a time when modern medicine was unavailable.

The “logic” behind them is internally consistent within each culture: for Malays, keeping the pregnancy “cool” (to avoid dangerous heat) and the postpartum period “warm” (to restore lost heat and dispel wind) made sense in humoral theory. Chinese yin-yang theory similarly taught that a postpartum body lacking yang must be replenished with hot foods. Indian Ayurveda explicitly states that postpartum mothers are dominated by Vata (cold/dry) and must be treated with warmth and oiliness, whereas pregnancy can increase Pitta (heat) so cooling foods are gentler.

These frameworks persisted because they did occasionally yield practical results (e.g. ginger really does warm you up and improve digestion, resting for 40 days does help recovery). They were also reinforced by anecdotes – if a woman who broke the rules fell ill, it “proved” the rule’s value.

Modern Medical Evaluation:

With today’s medical knowledge, we can say some traditional practices have merit, but many are simply myths or exaggerated fears. Importantly, categorising foods as “hot” or “cold” is not a scientific nutritional concept – it’s a cultural classification.

Food effects on the body come from nutrients and chemicals, not an inherent temperature quality. For example, a pineapple or papaya is rich in vitamins and enzymes; there is no clinical evidence it induces miscarriage. Thus, avoiding most fruits or vegetables during pregnancy (or postpartum) is not medically necessary and can even be detrimental.

Obstetricians emphasize that a pregnant woman needs a variety of nutrients from all food groups, and there is “no scientific evidence that you should avoid ‘cooling’ foods as well as fruits and vegetables when you’re pregnant.” On the contrary, cutting out produce could deprive mother and baby of vitamins, fiber and antioxidants.

Similarly, postpartum, a diet of only rice, meat, and ginger lacks vitamin C and could lead to constipation or delayed healing. Balance and moderation are key. If a new mother’s cultural beliefs make her wary of certain foods, healthcare providers often suggest substitutions (e.g. if citrus is “too cooling,” she can get vitamin C from a supplement or other fruits she’s comfortable with).

Hydration and Hygiene:

Many traditional confinement rules around bathing and drinking have been debunked by medical science. For instance, the myth that bathing or washing hair causes “wind” to enter and harm the mother has “no basis… at all”, as one medical review flatly states.

In fact, good hygiene (regular showers, proper wound care) is crucial to prevent skin or uterine infections after childbirth. Doctors encourage at least a sponge bath daily if a full bath is culturally not done for a few days.

The idea that drinking cold water harms recovery is also unsupported – the body’s core temperature won’t be affected by a glass of cool water. Staying well-hydrated is essential, particularly for breastfeeding mothers who need extra fluid to produce milk. Traditional drinks like red date tea or dill water are fine, but there is no harm in drinking plain warm water, and in fact women should not restrict fluid intake for fear of urinating more (postpartum diuresis is normal as the body sheds excess fluid from pregnancy).

Modern medicine would rather see a mother urinate often (to avoid urinary infections and flush fluids) than hold back on water.

Role of Herbal Remedies and “Hot” Foods: Some confinement foods do have health benefits. Ginger has anti-nausea and anti-inflammatory effects, turmeric is anti-inflammatory, and many herbs used (fenugreek, dill, black pepper) can aid digestion or lactation. Eating warming, easily digestible meals is consistent with medical advice to avoid heavy, greasy foods right after birth (since digestion may be weak post-labor).

However, problems arise if these are taken to excess. For example, Chinese practices of consuming large quantities of rice wine or sesame oil daily can be problematic: excessive alcohol can pass into breast milk and affect the newborn’s liver or neurodevelopment. High-calorie tonics may also contribute to unhealthy weight retention if not moderated.

Moreover, many traditional herbal mixtures are not well-studied; some could contain undisclosed ingredients or interact with medications. Doctors advise that herbs be used cautiously – in small amounts as seasoning is fine, but concentrated herbal supplements should be discussed with a healthcare provider, especially if the mother is on any medication.

Psychological and Social Factors:

One aspect where traditional practices excel is in providing social support and structured care for the new mother. The “confinement” period essentially forces the extended family to rally around the mother: cooking for her, doing house chores, and keeping her company.

This can reduce her stress and allow her to rest, which is undoubtedly beneficial for recovery and mental health. A systematic review of worldwide postpartum customs found that these rituals “allow the mother to be ‘mothered’ for a period of time after birth”, and can facilitate the transition to motherhood and possibly have beneficial health effects.

From a modern perspective, this kind of support network is something to cherish, as postpartum depression and exhaustion are less likely when a mother has help and feels cared for.

In Malaysia, many modern clinics actually encourage culturally sensitive practices because they know a happy, rested mom recovers faster. They will rarely tell a patient “don’t do confinement” – instead, they’ll say “by all means, follow the cultural practices that make you and your family comfortable, but don’t ignore medical advice.” For instance, a doctor might say it’s fine to avoid cabbage or to wear socks and keep warm if it gives you peace of mind, so long as you take your vitamins, drink enough fluids, and seek medical help for any issues.

---

Myths vs. Facts

To summarize some common beliefs and what medical science says:

Myth: “Cold foods or drinks will harm a pregnant/postpartum woman (cause miscarriage, cause ‘wind’ illness, etc).”

Fact: There is no scientific evidence that cold or “cooling” foods cause miscarriage or illness. Miscarriages are almost never caused by foods.

Similarly, postpartum health issues (like joint pain or colic in the baby) are not caused by the mother drinking cold water or eating a fruit. Moderate temperature foods are perfectly safe, though extremely spicy or acidic foods might irritate digestion in some individuals.

Myth: “Avoid bathing and cold exposure after childbirth, or ‘wind’ will enter the body and make you sick.”

Fact: Personal hygiene is vital after childbirth – bathing (with warm water) is encouraged by doctors as soon as the mother is steady on her feet. There’s no mysterious “wind” that will invade; infections come from bacteria, which are actually kept at bay by cleanliness. Staying comfortably warm is fine, but living in a sweat for weeks without bathing can lead to skin rashes or wound infections. Using a fan or air-conditioning in hot weather is actually helpful to prevent overheating; it does not cause postpartum illness.

Myth: “One must consume a lot of ‘heaty’ ingredients like ginger, wine, jamu herbs to recover and expel wind.”

Fact: Nutrition and adequate calories are indeed important for recovery, but there’s no medical requirement that they be from “heaty” ingredients specifically. Small amounts of these traditional foods are generally harmless and can be beneficial (ginger, for example). Yet, consuming them to excess can be risky – e.g., too much alcohol in cooking can affect the breastfeeding baby, and certain herbal components could have side effects.

The body naturally contracts the uterus and expels lochia without needing potent concoctions; gentle uterine tonics like turmeric or fenugreek can aid the process, but moderation is key.

Myth: “After delivery I should eat only certain ‘rich’ foods (like liver, meat, and herbal tonics) and avoid vegetables, or my body will stay weak.”

Fact: While iron and protein from meats are important to rebuild blood, a well-balanced diet including vegetables and fruits is crucial for vitamins, fiber, and overall healing.

Doctors stress that no single “superfood” can replace a balance of food groups. Even vegetarians can recover well by eating a variety of plant-based proteins and taking supplements as needed.

So, women should not feel compelled to eat only traditional confinement dishes if it means missing out on other nutritious foods they prefer.

---

Conclusion: Balancing Tradition and Medicine

Traditional pregnancy and postpartum practices in Malaysia’s Malay, Chinese, and Indian communities are a rich part of the cultural heritage. They were born from centuries of collective wisdom aiming to protect mothers and babies.

Many of these practices – especially the emphasis on rest, warmth, and family support – have real benefits for new mothers’ well-being. However, when it comes to the hot vs cold food classifications and strict taboos, modern medical logic finds that some are myths without scientific support. Following them rigidly can sometimes do more harm than good (through malnutrition, dehydration, or poor hygiene).

So, should people still follow these practices? The answer can be nuanced.

There is no harm in observing most of these customs in moderation if they provide comfort and if basic health needs are still met. Cultural practices often have a strong placebo and psychological benefit – if a mother believes drinking her herbal soup and avoiding “cold” foods will make her better, this positive mindset itself can aid recovery (and it keeps anxious relatives happy, reducing stress on the mom!).

On the other hand, people should feel empowered to let go of practices that are clearly outdated or detrimental. For example, enduring thirst because one is not “allowed” water, or staying in a sweaty room in fear of the fan, are unnecessary sufferings that no new mother should have to bear.

Modern Malaysian mothers are increasingly adapting these traditions: some may do a shorter confinement, or they’ll follow the diet but also take physician-prescribed supplements to cover any nutritional gaps. Others might embrace certain rituals (like massage and hot soup) but ignore others (like avoiding bathing or social isolation). This pragmatic approach is wise – it keeps the helpful parts of tradition and discards the unhelpful.

Healthcare professionals today try to work with cultural practices rather than against them.

They advise: by all means enjoy your jamu, your ginger chicken, and your 40 days of TLC from family – but also listen to medical advice, eat balanced meals, stay clean, and seek help if any complication arises.

In summary, the “hot-cold” food system is a fascinating blend of cultural logic and myth. It doesn’t perfectly align with scientific understanding of nutrition or physiology, but it has value in how it encourages structured care.

Women can honor these traditions while also following today’s medical recommendations. The ultimate goal is the same for tradition and modern medicine: a healthy mother and baby.

As long as that goal is kept in mind, a balance of tradition and evidence-based practice can be the best of both worlds – providing physical recovery as well as emotional comfort for the new mother.

---

Sources:

Laderman, C. (1987). Destructive heat and cooling prayer: Malay humoralism in pregnancy, childbirth and the postpartum period. Social Science & Medicine, 25(4), 357-365 – (Malay humoral beliefs equating cold with fertility and heat with illness).

Othman, S. et al. (2017). Food taboos of Malay pregnant women attending antenatal check-up in Kuala Lumpur. – (Survey data on Malay pregnancy food avoidances; pineapple, “hot” foods taboo).

Khamis, N. et al. (2019). Perception on Postpartum Dietary Practices among Malay Women – IIUM Journal of Allied Health Sciences, 3(3) – (100% prevalence of Malay confinement practices, types of foods avoided for being ‘cold’, etc.).

SHS Conference Paper (2018). Postnatal Care Practices among the Malays, Chinese and Indians: A Comparison – (Descriptions of each culture’s confinement customs in Malaysia).

Teo, P. et al. (2018). 17 Pregnancy Food Myths Busted – HealthXchange (SingHealth) – (Modern medical perspective debunking “cooling foods cause miscarriage,” etc.).

HealthHub SG (2021). Confinement Practices and Myths – (Medical advice refuting myths: bathing, drinking water, etc.).

Dennis, C-L. et al. (2007). Traditional Postpartum Practices and Rituals: A Qualitative Systematic Review – Birth, 34(4) – (Global overview of postpartum rituals, noting benefits of social support and rest).

Banyan, V. (2016). Birthing Ayurveda: Postpartum – Nurturing the Mother – (Ayurvedic explanation of postpartum being a cold/vata state requiring warm, oily care).

NuskhaKitchen (2025). Guide to Taseer (heating/cooling) Foods for Pregnancy & Postpartum – (Contemporary Ayurvedic tips on cooling foods in pregnancy vs heating in postpartum).

Leung, P. et al. (2016). A Comparison of Practices During the Confinement Period among Chinese, Malay, and Indian Mothers in Singapore – Birth, 43(3) – (Study finding high prevalence of certain practices; massage more common in Malays, etc., generally showing all groups avoid “cold” and prioritize rest).